Education and Training In Social Context
Informal Education
  • Primary socialisation (learning of basic values, roles, statuses, norms, etc)
  • Family groups, Peer groups, etc.
  • Social control
  • Self concept / self development (Mead - The Self, the "I" and the "Me")
Formal Education
  • Secondary socialisation (learning of wider social values, roles, statuses, norms)
  • Social control
  • Historical development in England and Wales:
  • 1870 Elementary Education Act (Forster)
  • 1918 Education Act (Fisher)
  • 1944 Education Act (Butler): Tripartite system. Based on work of Burt.
    • Grammar (academic)
    • Secondary Modern (practical, general, non-academic)
    • Technical (practical, higher level) - not fully implemented
  • 1965 Circular 10/65 (Comprehensive schooling)
  • 1975 Williams (Labour): Widespread introduction of Comprehensive schooling
  • 1980 Education Act (Assisted Places scheme)

    1988 Education Reform Act (National Curriculum, Key Stage testing, Local Management of Schools, Grant-maintained status ("opting-out").

Cultural Transmission
  • Processes by which different societies, cultures (e.g. social classes) and subcultures transmit variety of different values, beliefs (ideologies), norms.
  • Agencies: Family, Work, Religion, Media, Education.
Cultural Reproduction
  • Process by which different societies, cultures and subcultures reproduce both themselves (socialisation) and relationships of dominance / subordination.
  • Agencies: Education, Media, Religion, Family, Work.
The above can be linked to:
  • Different theories of society (Functionalist, Marxist, Interactionist, Feminist, etc.)
  • Different theories of role of education within society (Functionalist, Marxist, Interactionist, Feminist, Deschoolers, etc.)
  • The Formal curriculum (content, social construction of, etc.)
  • The Hidden curriculum (the experience of schooling, social learning, etc.)
  • Differential Achievement (Class, Gender, Ethnicity)
Perspectives on Cultural Transmission and Reproduction in Education
a. Functionalism    
  • Socialisation (secondary) - Learning instrumental relationships
  • Allocation (of individuals into future adult roles)
  • Differentiation (selection process)
  • Meritocracy
  • Social stratification - academic and vocational training
  • Transmission of societal values and norms
  • Reproduction of society
b. Marxism    
  • Transmission of ruling class ideologies through organised education:
  • "Ideological State Apparatuses" (ISA's) and
  • "Repressive State Apparatuses" (RSA's)- Althusser
  • Dominant Ideology
  • Cultural Hegemony (Gramsci, Poulantzas)
  • Relative autonomy (of education system from other institutions - Giroux)
  • Correspondence Theory (Bowles and Gintis)
  • Cultural Capital (Bourdieu and Passeron)
  • Reproduction of social inequality (structured inequality)
Alternatives to Traditional Forms of Education
  • Radical: Philosophical opposition to traditional school organisations:

    Summerhill (private, democratic)
    Steiner Schools (education through play - informal learning)

  • Mainstream: Different forms of traditional school organisations

    City Technology Colleges (based around Information Technology)
    Magnet schools (specialise in particular subjects - eg. Music, Languages)

  • Supplemental: Additional / Alternative, non-school based forms of education

    Saturday Schools (Mirza - Afro-Caribbean's in Britain)

    Home Schooling

Deschooling and Critique of Professions    
  • Dewey (early 20th century)
  • Illich ("Deschooling Society1971) / Perelman ("School's Out…" 1992)
  • Status Groups (eg. Professions - teachers)
  • Professional closure (control of intake)
  • Control of knowledge / formal curriculum
  • Organisation of teaching process
  • Monopoly of knowledge
  • Validity - of knowledge, of realisation of knowledge (exams, etc.)
  • Subordination, Dependence, Conformity, Competition, Fatalism…
  • Streaming / Banding - replication of economic stratification
Policies / Provisions    
  • Reformist Liberalism (Comprehensives, Compensatory: Educational Priority Areas (UK): Plowden Report 1967, Operation Headstart (USA, 1950's), Nursery Schooling, Education Action Areas (1999).
  • Multi-culturalism, Anti-racism, Special needs
  • Market Liberalism (Thatcherism / New Right): See 1988 Education Reform Act
  • Academic / Vocational subjects
  • Tri-partite system / Comprehensivisation
  • The New Vocationalism:1974 onwards (see Finn):
  • NVQ, GNVQ, Key Skills, Records of Achievement, Work Experience (TEVI), Modular A-levels, A/S levels.
  • "Skill shortages" in labour market (YTS, YT, Modern Apprenticeships)
  • Manpower Services Commission / Training and Enterprise Councils (TECs)
  • Adult Education: Expansion of FE and HE. Conversion of Polytechnics.
  • Public Schools (fee-paying): Cultural transmission and Reproduction of Elites
  • Social networks / social and status inequalities
  • Meritocracy (contest and sponsored mobility)
  • Postmodernism (changing nature of employment)
Inside Schools
Organisation, Structure and Institutional Processes    
  • Types of school (State, Private, Selective, Non-selective)
  • School hierarchies (see Alternative Schooling)
  • Streaming, setting, banding
  • Role of School Governors
  • Subjects / Subject divisions (Arts / Sciences)
  • Formal curriculum and hidden curriculum
  • Discipline (Truancy, Expulsions, Suspensions)
  • Conformity / Attendance
  • Testing: Key Stages 1 - 4(GCSE), Public examinations
  • Pupil subcultures
  • Teacher - Pupil relationships / Pupil-Pupil relationships (bullying?)
Social Construction and Organisation of Knowledge    
  • "Societies select…things they consider worthy of being known" (Weber)
  • Postmodernism and moral / cultural relativism

The formal curriculum:

  • Organisation, Selection and Stratification of knowledge (Young)
  • Academic (theoretical) / Vocational (practical) divide.
  • High status and low status knowledge
  • The New Vocationalism (Finn)
  • Power: Who decides what counts as valid knowledge? / Relationships

The hidden curriculum:

  • Gendered curriculum (especially post-16). (Impact of National Curriculum on pre-16 subject gendering)
  • Secondary socialisation (Parsons)
  • Labelling theory (Fuller, Nash, Hargreaves)
  • Self-fulfilling prophecies / Negotiated realities
  • Ghosting (Meighan)
  • Role models (teachers, pupils)
  • Patriarchal ideology
  • Language codes (restricted / elaborated: Berstein)
  • Immediate / Deferred gratification
  • Pupil subcultures (reactive / independent)
  • League Tables / school status
Educational Achievement
Patterns and Inequalities (UK)    
  • Class: upper / middle achieve more (all levels)
  • Gender: Females achieve more (up to A-level)
  • Ethnicity: Whites, Asians achieve more (all levels)
  • Afro-Caribbean females achieve more than Working class males
  • Region: Affluent areas achieve more / inner cities achieve least
Life Chances (Weber)    
  • Relationship between educational achievement and work (by class, gender, ethnic group). Social networks (especially upper / middle class)
  • University entrance (upper / middle class dominated)
  • Public schools and Oxbridge entrance
  • Cultural Capital (family, education, wealth, etc.).
  • Meritocracy and equality opportunity (Davis and Moore thesis)
  • Correspondence Theory (Reproduction of class / gender / ethnic inequalities)
  • IQ (genetic basis of intelligence?): Problems of definition / measurement.
  • Academic / Vocational divide
  • Education for adult life or Training for work?
Theories and Explanations:    
Non-school factors [Material]
  • Material deprivation (Poverty, Income, Employment, Diet, etc.)
  • Employment opportunities

Non-school factors [Cultural]

  • Cultural deprivation (and compensatory education: Halsey)
  • Cultural difference:
  • Cultural Capital (Bourdieu)
  • Language (Bernstein)
  • Positional theory (Boudon, Banks)
  • Family (parental attitudes - class, gender and ethnicity: Douglas)
  • Primary socialisation (especially related to single-parent families / males / females)
  • Perceptions of employment opportunities
  • Patriarchal ideologies and relationships
  • Racism

School factors [Material]

  • School (region, condition)

School factors [Cultural:]

  • Labelling theory / self-fulfilling prophecy
  • Streaming / Banding / Setting
  • Class, gender, ethnic background
  • Formal Curriculum (middle class knowledge)
  • Hidden curriculum
  • Anti-school subcultures (Male: Willis / Female: Lees)
  • Language and textbooks (anti-female / black bias)
  • Gender relationships (teacher -pupil / pupil-pupil)
  • Gendered curriculum (patriarchal)
  • Teacher expectations, attitudes and behaviour (Nash)
  • Single / Dual sex schooling
  • Examination and skill changes (GCSE, A-level, Coursework)
  • Changing attitudes to / expectations of work (males and females)
Home